…746 and counting… Authors, here’s a reviewer/blogger to demand yer respect… Cathy McNally… #TBSU…

…commitment… paying it forward… paying it backward… paying it in any direction yeez can think of…a remarkable blogger by emb’dy’s measure… Lads and Lassies of Blog Land, I give yeez the redoubtable Cathy McNally… if I thought my hillock of To Be Read pile on Kindle was daunting, have a squint at this Lady’s… a veritable Literary Everest to get through… even her blog handle, 746 Books–Confessions of a Book Buying Addict (“www.746books.wordpress.com ‘)  kinda gives it away a bit…


Cathy is a ‘forty-something mother of twins from ‘Norn Irn’ (Northern Ireland to the rest of yeez)… she dubs herself a ‘fledgling blogger’, but she’s certainly won great respect from this ol’ Jurassic… go on over and support her blog, good people… here’s a recent sample of some of her review work… LUV IT!

Number 728 …..

‘Tampa’ by Alissa Nutting


I need to start by saying that I can handle an unlikeable lead character. Hell, I love an unlikeable lead character. Keith Talent, Patrick Bateman, Mrs Danvers are all great, memorable characters. Great protagonists have no need to be likeable; they just need to be compelling. A character can have a dubious moral code and still move the reader, as long as that code can be understood but not necessarily shared by the reader.

With that in mind, meet Celeste Price. She is a beautiful, wealthy, married, 26-year-old blonde who drives to her teaching job at a Florida high school in a red sports car. She’s also a self-obsessed, vain, amoral sociopath who tends to get what she wants. And what she wants? 14 year old boys.  She’s not your average paedophile then, but paedophile she is and this is 265 pages of intentional shock and salaciousness set inside the head of an obsessive sexual predator. Now I have just read The Seven Days of Peter Crumb where I was totally invested in and moved by the plight of a murdering, raping, mentally ill psychopath. Celeste has the potential to be that type of character, so it’s is a shame then that I just got so bloody bored of her.

Nutting attended the same Florida high school as Debra Lafave who, in 2004 gained notoriety for seducing one of her 14 year old students. Had I known that Lafave escaped a custodial sentence on the grounds that she was too attractive for jail, I may have given up on Tampa. I was really only reading to the end to see Celeste get her comeuppance. But Nutting stays pretty faithful to the Lafave plot.

As well as the Lafave case, Nutting also wants to draw comparisons to Nabokov’s Lolita. Like Humbert, Celeste chooses her victim with care and sleeps with the parent of her victim in order to remain int he illicit relationship. However, to compare the two any further than that would be like comparing Goodfellas to Mickey Blue Eyes on the grounds that they both contain gangsters.Nabokov’s writing is lyrical, Nutting’s is banal. There are no explicit sex scenes in Lolita, Tampa has little else.

When she’s not having sex with children, Celeste is thinking about it, masturbating about it or having unavoidable sex with adults and fantasising about it. This is a book that is trying really, really hard to shock, but any shock is very quickly dissipated by over indulgence and by about half way through I started skimming the dirty but dull sex scenes in the hope that there might be something approaching character development or plot around the corner. No such luck.

“I knew that if I was going to write this I was going to refuse to euphemise, I was not going to hide behind language,” says Nutting. Yet that is exactly what she does. Tampa hides behind the cheap pornographic set pieces – the taking of Jack’s virginity goes on for 10 PAGES – to mask the fact that the satire it is striving for is absent. There is a lack of any kind of exploration of why Celeste is the way she is. The same criticism can be levelled at American Psycho, but at least it contains humour and wit and targets the wider empty toxic environment that Patrick Bateman exemplifies. For the satire to be successful, Celeste has to be aware that she is trapped within her own egoism but she’s not. We are merely trapped there with her and it’s not a pleasant place to be. Given no broader moral point, the story is as empty, shallow and superficial as its protagonist and the reader is left with nothing to invest in.


Debra Lafave, the ‘inspiration’ for Celeste Price.

All other characters are, without exception, two-dimensional, the continuous descriptions of every type of sex imaginable are wearisome and some of the plotting is questionable. Does Celeste’s classroom have no windows? Is that kind of acrobatic sex possible in the back seat of a convertible sports car? How can her cop husband not realise he is being drugged on a regular basis? Why on earth call it Tampa if it doesn’t make any discernible difference to the plot?

Given the current climate of Operation Yewtree and the currency of the subject matter, it is clear that there is a point to be made about female sexual offenders and how society views them, but Tampa is not the book to do it.


Thanks for being there, Cathy… LUV IT!




Filed under Blether, Scribbling & Stuff

9 responses to “…746 and counting… Authors, here’s a reviewer/blogger to demand yer respect… Cathy McNally… #TBSU…

  1. Thank you so much Seumas, you are a true star! Support like this is priceless.


  2. MM Jaye

    Done, Seumas! Followed Cathy’s blog and connected on Twitter!


  3. Fabulous, well thought out, professional review of a book which obviously failed to inspire.
    I know we are not supposed to judge a book by its cover but in all honesty I would not have picked this one up to even read the blurb!
    Thank you for sharing your find, Sir Gallacher. I’ll be popping over to visit Cathy’s blog!


  4. laurie27wsmith

    Direct and to the point. I actually read the whole thing Seumas. 🙂


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.